Baseball Hall of Fame: The steroid question

on January 14, 2013M at 12:30 pm

My brother sent me a great email over the weekend. He came up with fascinating point about the Baseball Hall of Fame voting.

?On March 17, 2005, Mark McGuire repeatedly said to the Congressional committee: ?I?m not here to talk about the past.? (In recent Cooperstown voting) the baseball writers looked at their ballots, sent them in blank, and in essence wrote at the bottom: ?we?re not here to talk about the past.??

Here?s what I like about that. While McGwire, Barry Bonds, Sammy Sosa, Roger Clemens and Rafael Palmeiro were overwhelmingly rejected for Hall of Fame induction, there remains a faction of the baseball community that believes the Hall of Fame should include them in some manner. And here?s their theory: You can?t rewrite history. Those home runs and awesome statistics happened. You can?t ignore them.

But here?s my response. We are not rewriting history in baseball. Yes, those home runs happened and those statistics were recorded. Tainted by doping. And much to baseball?s credit, they were not wiped out. Those records still stand. Bonds is baseball?s career home run leader. The games and the titles won by those ballplayers have not been stricken from the recordbook. This is not the NCAA, which dares to spit in the face of fans by ?vacating? victories and championships, which is an affront not to the guilty, but to the public which funds collegiate sports.

The difference in baseball is this. While those things happened ? those home run hits and those strikeouts recorded and those ballgames won ? we are not compelled to honor them. Not compelled to commemorate them.

That?s what the Baseball Hall of Fame is. It?s a place to honor its past. It is NOT a place to record its past. Baseball?s history is well-documented in literally thousands of places. Cooperstown is not the Library of Congress (at least not its Hall of Fame side).

In fact, the Baseball Hall of Fame has never stood taller than during the steroid scandal. Never stood taller than in recent years. Cooperstown allows us to separate. Yes, guys can cheat the game, and manipulate the results and the records, and in some ways we have to accept it. But we don?t have to like it. The Hall of Fame is the concept by which we announce what we like. By which we announce who is great and who is honorable and who deserves to be cheered.

That?s why the likes of McGwire and Clemens and Bonds and, yes, Pete Rose, should be kept out of Cooperstown. Because they are void of honor, and the Hall of Fame is a place of honor. It?s value never has been higher.

?

?

?

-------------Berry Tramel can be heard Monday through Friday from 4:40-5:20 p.m. on The Sports Animal radio network in Oklahoma City, including AM 640 and FM 98.1. E-mail Berry, follow him on Twitter at @BerryTramel, Like him on Facebook, or visit his website.

Thank you for joining our conversation on Berry Tramel's Blog. We encourage your discussion but ask that you stay within the bounds of our commenting and posting policy.

Source: http://blog.newsok.com/berrytramel/2013/01/14/baseball-hall-of-fame-the-steroid-question/

apple dividend snow white and the huntsman snow white and the huntsman rupaul drag race walking dead comic kratom broncos